BS/MD Admissions by College Admissions Partners

Making Medical School Dreams a Reality

  • Home
  • Testimonials
  • 11 Steps to Become the Strongest BS/MD Candidate.
  • Contact College Admissions Partners
  • Resources
  • Services
  • BS/MD Admissions
  • Parents
  • Student
  • Meet the College Admission Consultant
  • Free Consultation
  • Blog
  • Campaigns
  • Sitemap
  • #6868 (no title)

Making Medical School Dreams a Reality

  • Home
  • BS/MD
    Admissions
  • Resources
    • Admissions
    • Application Process
    • College of the Month
    • College Rankings
    • Info to Know
    • Services
    • Admissions Timeline
    • Transfer Help
    • Weekly Resource
  • Free
    Consultation
  • About Us
    • Todd Johnson
    • Kelley Anne Johnson
    • Do You Need Help?
    • How Do We Help Your Student?
    • College Admissions Partners in the Media
    • Testimonials
  • Blog

Posted on 08.19.09 by Todd Johnson 1 Comment

The Problem with College Rankings

Lawrence UniversityI reported this morning on an article on Inside Higher Ed called “Reputation without Rigor.” One of the comments to that article was by Steven Syverson, the Vice President for Enrollment at Lawrence University in Wisconsin. Steve’s comments were so well said that I asked his permission to repost them on the blog. I agree 100% with Steve’s comments.

“With the exception of the peer rating data (which wouldn’t pass muster as valid social science research at any legitimate college), US News actually does a reasonable job of collecting data. Each of their data elements offers some value in understanding a particular college. The magazine’s mistake is in combining the individual data elements into a single rank for each college. It sells magazines, but it actually does a great disservice to the very students they claim to want to serve. The rankings imply that there is a “best” college and a second and third best college, etc. But “best college” really has meaning only in the context of each student. What serves students well is when college counseling professionals (and parents) help each student find their own best college match. These rankings distort the college search process for many students and, on the other side of the desk, a preoccupation with these rankings can interfere with good decision-making at colleges. One of the strengths of American higher education is the diversity of colleges available — the rankings tend to encourage greater homogeneity rather than celebrating the differences in mission and style of delivery.”

Thank you Steve for saying so well what many of us believe is the problem with college rankings.

You can trust us to help you find the best college for your needs. We offer a FREE 1/2 hour consultation to discuss your needs for college admissions counseling. Give us a call now at 888-970-BSMD(2763) or drop us an email.

Categories: College Admissions Counseling Tags: college rankings

Todd Johnson's avatar

Todd Johnson

Todd Johnson is the founder of College Admissions Partners. Todd regularly teaches other independent college admissions counselors and is the country's leading expert in BS/MD admissions. He is also the author of a best selling book on BS/MD admissions.

Trackbacks

  1. The Problem with College Rankings | Everyone Read It! says:
    September 1, 2009 at 8:16 pm

    […] Share on Facebook […]

Leave a Comment

Recent Posts

02.21.23

2023 Edition of the Book is Now Available

07.07.22

Do You Need A Competitive Research Program?

07.05.22

Do You Need To Start A Club?

06.30.22

Does It Matter Who You Shadow?

Categories

  • Accelerated Medical Program
  • Activities
  • Admissions
  • Applications
  • BS/MD Programs
  • College Admissions Counseling
  • College Application
  • College Financial Aid
  • College of the Month
  • College Planning
  • College Selection
  • College Testing
  • Doctor Shadowing
  • Essays
  • General Information
  • Interviews
  • Medical School
  • Pre-med
  • Research
  • Specific Programs

Email Sign-up

Get the latest updates delivered straight to your inbox.

Contact Us

32039 Danbury Ave.
Northfield, Minnesota 55057
888-970-BSMD(2763)
Email: todd@collegeadmissionspartners.com or
collegeadmitguy@gmail.

Resources

  • Admissions
  • Application Process
  • College Rankings
  • Info to Know
  • Admissions Timeline

About Us

  • Meet Todd Johnson
  • Meet Kelley Johnson
  • Do You Need Help?
  • How Do We Help Your Student?
  • College Admissions Partners in the Media
  • Testimonials

Sitemap | Website by Web Savvy Marketing

© 2006 – 2018 College Admissions Counseling