BS/MD Admissions by College Admissions Partners

Making Medical School Dreams a Reality

  • Home
  • Testimonials
  • 11 Steps to Become the Strongest BS/MD Candidate.
  • Contact College Admissions Partners
  • Resources
  • Services
  • BS/MD Admissions
  • Parents
  • Student
  • Meet the College Admission Consultant
  • Free Consultation
  • Blog
  • Campaigns
  • Sitemap
  • #6868 (no title)

Making Medical School Dreams a Reality

  • Home
  • BS/MD
    Admissions
  • Resources
    • Admissions
    • Application Process
    • College of the Month
    • College Rankings
    • Info to Know
    • Services
    • Admissions Timeline
    • Transfer Help
    • Weekly Resource
  • Free
    Consultation
  • About Us
    • Todd Johnson
    • Kelley Anne Johnson
    • Do You Need Help?
    • How Do We Help Your Student?
    • College Admissions Partners in the Media
    • Testimonials
  • Blog

Posted on 06.26.08 by Todd Johnson 3 Comments

U.S. News new features for 2009 college rankings

U.S. News has officially announced that they will have two new features in the 2009 edition of America’s Best Colleges.  The first new feature is that U.S. News has asked college presidents, provosts and admissions deans to name schools that are “up and coming” colleges. Given that one of the greatest criticism’s of the U.S. News rankings is that top college officials have little basis for rating other colleges, the peer assessment portion of the ratings, it is curious to see how these same officials will name “up and coming” colleges. Moreover, many top college officials have announced that they will no longer participate in the peer assessment ratings and presumably these same officials will refuse to participate in the “up and coming” rating.

The second new feature is that U.S. News has asked high school counselors for their views on undergraduate programs. While some high school counselors have a good understanding of many of the colleges to which their students apply, many more are too overworked to devote as much time as they would like to their students counseling needs. To think that these same counselors are going to have time to rank colleges or have the knowledge to adequately rank colleges is absurd.

I have always said that the U.S. News ranking issue can be helpful because of the raw numbers that are provided on various colleges. But to believe that colleges can be rated in the way attempted by U.S. News is ridiculous. And the two new “features” are clearly more focused on silly marketing rather than trying to provide legitimate helpful information to students and families in the college search process.

You can trust us to help you find the best college for your needs. We offer a FREE 1/2 hour consultation to discuss your needs for college admissions counseling. Give us a call now at 888-970-BSMD(2763) or drop us an email.

Categories: College Selection Tags: college rankings

Todd Johnson's avatar

Todd Johnson

Todd Johnson is the founder of College Admissions Partners. Todd regularly teaches other independent college admissions counselors and is the country's leading expert in BS/MD admissions. He is also the author of a best selling book on BS/MD admissions.

Comments

  1. Henry says

    August 12, 2008 at 9:52 am

    The U.S. News college rankings border on the absurd. The methodology favors inputs over outputs and gives unduly high measure (25% of the total score) to the “reputation” component. Reputation is part myth and part reality. The category should count for something in the formula, but not 25%.

    The Washington Monthly rankings, although lacking in any number of areas, at least measure some important outputs, such as number of graduates going on to earn doctoral degrees, dollar amount of scientific grants won and number of professional papers published.

  2. Avatar photoTodd Johnson says

    August 12, 2008 at 7:40 pm

    The Washington Monthly rankings really aren’t any better. Whether for good or bad, colleges change very slowly. Yet look at the rankings for Washington Monthly comparing the college’s current ranking and last year ranking. There is almost no consistency.

Trackbacks

  1. U.S. News 2009 college rankings : College Admissions Counseling says:
    August 22, 2008 at 8:02 am

    […] I reported earlier, U.S. News has added two new issues to consider in the rankings. Here are the results of the “Up and Coming Colleges” and “Guidance Counselor […]

Leave a Comment

Recent Posts

02.21.23

2023 Edition of the Book is Now Available

07.07.22

Do You Need A Competitive Research Program?

07.05.22

Do You Need To Start A Club?

06.30.22

Does It Matter Who You Shadow?

Categories

  • Accelerated Medical Program
  • Activities
  • Admissions
  • Applications
  • BS/MD Programs
  • College Admissions Counseling
  • College Application
  • College Financial Aid
  • College of the Month
  • College Planning
  • College Selection
  • College Testing
  • Doctor Shadowing
  • Essays
  • General Information
  • Interviews
  • Medical School
  • Pre-med
  • Research
  • Specific Programs

Email Sign-up

Get the latest updates delivered straight to your inbox.

Contact Us

32039 Danbury Ave.
Northfield, Minnesota 55057
888-970-BSMD(2763)
Email: todd@collegeadmissionspartners.com or
collegeadmitguy@gmail.

Resources

  • Admissions
  • Application Process
  • College Rankings
  • Info to Know
  • Admissions Timeline

About Us

  • Meet Todd Johnson
  • Meet Kelley Johnson
  • Do You Need Help?
  • How Do We Help Your Student?
  • College Admissions Partners in the Media
  • Testimonials

Sitemap | Website by Web Savvy Marketing

© 2006 – 2018 College Admissions Counseling